Based on my search of Ellen White's writings, here's what she wrote about pants for women:
## Ellen White on Pants for Women
Ellen White addressed the topic of pants for women specifically in the context of her "reform dress" advocacy in the 1860s-1870s. Her position was nuanced and focused on health, modesty, and practicality.
### Her Support for Women Wearing Pants (Under Specific Conditions):
**As Part of the Reform Dress:**
Ellen White actually advocated that women wear pants as part of a reformed style of dress. She wrote: "Whatever may be the length of the dress, females should clothe their limbs as thoroughly as the males. This may be done by wearing lined pants gathered into a band and fastened about the ankle, or made full and tapering at the bottom; and these should come down long enough to meet the shoe" (How to Live, No. 6, p. 64).
**For Health and Modesty:**
"The limbs should be clothed with pants, always cut after an approved pattern, made tapering to meet the instep of the shoe" (HR May 1, 1872).
"We believe it wrong to differ from others, unless it be necessary to differ in order to be right. In bearing the cross of adopting the reform dress, we are led by a sense of duty. And although it may appear objectionable to those who are governed by fashion, we claim that it is the most convenient, the most truly modest, and the most healthful style of dress worn by woman" (HR May 1, 1872).
### What She Opposed - The "American Costume":
Ellen White strongly opposed what was called the "American Costume," which was an extreme form of dress reform that made women look like men:
"There is still another style of dress which is adopted by a class of so-called dress reformers. They imitate the opposite sex as nearly as possible. They wear the cap, pants, vest, coat, and boots, the last of which is the most sensible part of the costume. Those who adopt and advocate this style of dress carry the so-called dress reform to very objectionable lengths. Confusion will be the result" (
1T 459.7).
### Her Recommended Reform Dress:
Ellen White's reform dress consisted of:
- A dress shortened to about 9-10 inches from the floor
- Pants worn underneath for warmth and modesty
- The entire outfit suspended from the shoulders rather than the hips
- Simple, unadorned styling
"The above-described dress we believe to be worthy of the name of the reform short dress... In wide contrast with this modest dress is the so-called American costume, resembling very nearly the dress worn by men. It consists of a vest, pants, and a dress resembling a coat and reaching about halfway from the hip to the knee. This dress I have opposed, from what has been shown me as in harmony with the word of God; while the other I have recommended as modest, comfortable, convenient, and healthful" (
1T 465.1).
### Why the Reform Dress Was Eventually Discontinued:
Ellen White explained that the reform dress was eventually laid aside because:
1. Many church members opposed it and caused dissension
2. Some who adopted it didn't follow the proper pattern, making it look "grotesque and untidy"
3. Others complained it was a "heavy burden"
4. The controversy was destroying unity in the church
"While none were compelled to adopt the reform dress, our people could and should have appreciated its advantages and accepted it as a blessing. The evil results of an opposite course may now be seen" (
4T 639.1).
### Her Later Counsel:
After discontinuing advocacy for the specific reform dress, Ellen White gave this guidance: "Follow the customs in dress so far as they conform to health principles. Let our sisters dress plainly, as many do, having the dress of good, durable material, appropriate for this age, and let not the dress question fill the mind" (
3SM 242.4).
### Summary:
Ellen White supported women wearing pants when they were:
- Part of a modest, healthful dress style
- Worn under an appropriate-length dress
- Designed for comfort, health, and modesty
- Not imitating men's clothing
She opposed pants when they were part of mannish attire that confused gender distinctions. Her primary concerns were health, modesty, and maintaining appropriate gender distinctions while allowing women practical, comfortable clothing.