Ellen White's position on segregation was **complex and contextual**, reflecting both her strong opposition to racial prejudice as sin while also advocating for practical approaches that would allow ministry to continue in the hostile racial climate of the post-Civil War South.
## Ellen White's Fundamental Opposition to Racial Prejudice
Ellen White viewed racial prejudice as fundamentally sinful and contrary to God's will:
**Prejudice as Sin:**
"What should be done for the colored race has long been a vexed question, because professed Christians have not had the Spirit of Christ... Men have thought it necessary to plan in such a way as to meet the prejudice of the white people; and a wall of separation in religious worship has been built up between the colored people and the white people" (
SWk 19.2).
**Comparison to Jewish-Gentile Prejudice:**
"Is not this prejudice against the colored people on the part of the white people similar to that which was cherished by the Jews against the Gentiles?... Christ worked throughout His life to break down this prejudice" (
SWk 19.2).
**Spiritual Equality:**
"All are one in Christ. Birth, station, nationality, or color cannot elevate or degrade men. The character makes the man" (
SWk 12.2).
## Her Pragmatic Approach to Segregation
Despite her theological opposition to racial prejudice, Ellen White advocated for **practical segregation** in certain contexts, particularly in the South, as a strategic necessity:
**Separate Churches:**
"In regard to white and colored people worshiping in the same building, this cannot be followed as a general custom with profit to either party—especially in the South. The best thing will be to provide the colored people who accept the truth, with places of worship of their own" (
9T 206.3).
**Rationale for Separation:**
"Let the colored believers be provided with neat, tasteful houses of worship. Let them be shown that this is done not to exclude them from worshiping with white people, because they are black, but in order that the progress of the truth may be advanced" (
9T 206.4).
**Educational Segregation:**
"There is a work to be done in opening schools to teach the colored people alone, unmixed with whites, and there will be a successful work done in this way" (
SWk 92.3).
## Her Reasoning for Practical Segregation
Ellen White's advocacy for segregation was **strategic rather than ideological**:
**Protecting the Work:**
"The colored people should not urge that they be placed on an equality with white people... So far as possible, everything that would stir up the race prejudice of the white people should be avoided. There is danger of closing the door so that our white laborers will not be able to work in some places in the South" (
9T 214.3).
**Avoiding Violence:**
"Any mingling of the white people with the colored people, as sleeping in their houses, or showing them friendship as would be shown by the whites to those of their own color, is exasperating to the white people of the South" (
SWk 83.2).
**Practical Ministry Concerns:**
"Let as little as possible be said about the color line, and let the colored people work chiefly for those of their own race" (
9T 206.2).
## Her Vision for the Future
Ellen White believed segregation was a **temporary necessity**, not God's ultimate will:
**Future Integration:**
"When the Holy Spirit is poured out, there will be a triumph of humanity over prejudice in seeking the salvation of the souls of human beings. God will control minds. Human hearts will love as Christ loved. And the color line will be regarded by many very differently from the way in which it is now regarded" (
9T 209.1).
**Conversion Changes Hearts:**
"As the truth is brought to bear upon the minds of both colored and white people, as souls are thoroughly converted, they will become new men and women in Christ Jesus... Those who are converted among the white people will experience a change in their sentiments. The prejudice which they have inherited and cultivated toward the colored race will die away" (
SWk 22.1).
## Her Criticism of Exclusion
Ellen White strongly opposed **complete exclusion** of Black people from white religious gatherings:
**Against Total Exclusion:**
"Let not the colored people be excluded from the religious assemblies of the white people. They have no chance to exchange their superstitious exercises for a worship that is more sacred and elevating if they are shut out from association with intelligent white people" (
SWk 33.1).
**Church Membership:**
"You have no license from God to exclude the colored people from your places of worship. Treat them as Christ's property, which they are, just as much as yourselves. They should hold membership in the church with the white brethren" (
SWk 15.2).
## Summary
Ellen White was **against segregation as a principle** but **advocated for it as a temporary strategy** in the hostile racial climate of the post-Civil War South. She viewed racial prejudice as sin and believed in the spiritual equality of all races, but she also recognized that immediate integration would provoke violent opposition that would destroy the possibility of ministry to both races. Her position was pragmatic rather than ideological - she saw segregation as a necessary evil to preserve the opportunity for gospel work, while looking forward to a time when converted hearts would overcome racial prejudice.